Your web browser is out of date. Update your browser for more security, speed and the best experience on this site.

Update your browser
Defending the power of our states since 2009
logo

what are you looking for?

what are you looking for?

Blog

Safe States: The Essential Foundation
Trent England • Nov 18, 2026

What does it take to run for president? There are many answers, but one is certain. A legitimate candidate must have a base of states where voters already support him (or her) or his political party. Those so-called “safe states” are the essential foundation for any serious campaign.

On Election Day, voters in every state go to the polls. What they do matters—in every state.

The difference between safe and swing states is the voters. It’s a question of what the voters are likely to do, which means that all these voters matter. It is the voters who define, by their political choices, the outcome in their state—whether it is lopsided or close, predictable or uncertain.

Author Tara Ross describes this as a difference in timing: Voters in safe states make up their minds earlier, in such numbers that the outcome becomes more predictable than in other states. Here again, we see that what matters are the voters.

Another way to think about these states is to consider that some voters are “safe” while others “swing.” That is, some are firm supporters of a particular political party while others are not. If enough partisan voters favor one side in a particular state, those voters create a safe state. If they’re more divided, the voters create a swing state.

This works the same way in every statewide election (for U.S. senator, governor, etc.), determining the predictability of the outcome. At different levels, it is the same in every election. The closer it is likely to be, the more attention it gets—from the media, donors, voters, and pretty much everyone else. 

Of course, the media and their polls mostly define whether a race is expected to be close or not.

This shows how silly it is to claim that the National Popular Vote interstate compact would turn the nation into one big swing state. The media could just as easily claim, in a particular election, that the outcome is predictable and that the whole nation is one big safe state.

Remember when Dewey beat Truman? Or more recently the “blue wall,” the claim by many pundits, heavily trafficked in the media, that Democrats were guaranteed to win across the Rust Belt? That wall came crashing down. The media often gets it wrong. But right or wrong, the media would certainly declare some NPV elections all but over long before Election Day.

In our current system, what matters is what voters do within each state. This has many benefits. And the claimed drawback, the idea that safe states don’t matter, is simply false. Voters there matter first; they give candidates the legitimacy to run in the first place, and ultimately it is the choices voters make that determine what happens in every state.